AI Science Tracker

Timing side-channel in SM2 signatures on 64-bit ARM

OpenSSL · AI involvement attributed to AISLE autonomous system (specific model/version not disclosed)

Finding and attribution

The SM2 signing implementation on 64-bit ARM uses variable-time operations that create a timing signal. The vendor says this may permit private-key recovery, but remote recovery was not attempted by the reporter and the issue is not relevant to most TLS contexts absent a custom provider.

Product: OpenSSL. AI system: AISLE autonomous system (specific model/version not disclosed). Team / organization: AISLE.

CVE identifiers: CVE-2025-9231.

AI and human contribution (source account): AISLE’s October 29, 2025 article says its autonomous system discovered this CVE and individually describes the case. OpenSSL’s primary vulnerability record credits Stanislav Fort (Aisle Research) as finder; the September 30 vendor advisory documents the underlying issue, report history and fix. The exact model and AI-versus-researcher work split are not public. OpenSSL credits Stanislav Fort (Aisle Research) as finder; AISLE’s October 29 article says its autonomous system discovered this individually listed CVE among three of four 2025 OpenSSL CVEs. The exact model/human split is not public. AISLE article says all three system discoveries were identified Aug 9–16, while OpenSSL’s advisory gives a report date of Aug 18 for this case; that private-date discrepancy is preserved and neither date is treated as public AI attribution.

Human involvement is only described where the source account establishes it; unknown involvement does not mean none. Vendor confirmation of a flaw does not confirm every claim about AI contribution.

Discovery context: OpenSSL publicly disclosed the issue and fixes on September 30, 2025. AISLE publicly attributed the discovery to its autonomous system on October 29. The vendor’s conditions, severity and limitations are retained; no exploitation-in-the-wild claim is made.

Remediation status: fix documented. OpenSSL 3.5.4, 3.4.3, 3.3.5 and 3.2.6. The OpenSSL advisory lists affected and fixed release branches; deployment is not checked.

A source-documented fix does not establish installed patches or current safety. Source checking does not independently reproduce the finding or establish observed exploitation.

Disclosed 30 Sep 2025. AI attribution dated 29 Oct 2025. Sources checked 15 Nov 2026; these are separate dates, not a live installation check.

Recorded CVSS: Medium · highest recorded score 5.9. Documented technical effects: data disclosure.

Severity, consequences and exploitation evidence

Case grouping uses the highest recorded CVSS score, with its version-specific severity band. It is descriptive, not a combined or editorial risk index. All recorded assessments remain below; scores from different versions and sources may disagree. CVSS specifications define version-specific scoring and severity bands.

CVE-2025-9231: data disclosure.
Prerequisites / affected scope: On 64-bit ARM, timing during SM2 signatures could potentially permit remote private-key recovery; reporter observed a timing signal but did not attempt remote key recovery..
Exploitation evidence: The cited source does not establish exploitation in the wild.. Impact source · checked 16 Nov 2026.

Documented fix: OpenSSL 3.5.4, 3.4.3, 3.3.5 and 3.2.6. The OpenSSL advisory lists affected and fixed release branches; deployment is not checked.

Original evidence

Download this source record (JSON)

Open this case in the interactive tracker · Browse all static security cases